Post SA GPS Accuracy Measurements

Introduction

On May 1, 2000 the intentional degradation of GPS signals (called SA) was terminated. With this change a GPS without a DGPS unit attached became almost as accurate as a GPS with a DGPS attached. What follows is the result of 2 separate 24 hour tests, one with DGPS and one without.

Test setup

The tests were both done using a Motorola M12 Oncore GPS (sw. version 1.3) outputting Motorola Oncore-format Binary data which was logged to an attached NetBSD computer. The GPS antenna was a roof-mounted Trimble/Lowe antenna with 15 meters (50 ft.) of RG58A/U connecting the antenna to the GPS.

For the second test a Garmin GBR-21 DGPS radio tuned to the Point Blunt, CA Coast Guard station was used to provide the DGPS corrections. The Coast Guard station was located a mere 53 km (33 miles) away and provided the faster (thus lower delay) 200 baud corrections.


Plain GPS

Plain M12 plot
    samples:             86448 (24.0 hrs)
    ave lat:             37.55 degrees
    ave lon:             -121.94 degrees
    ave alt:             19.068 meters
    50.00% confidence:   4.2 meters
    68.27% confidence:   5.7 meters
    95.45% confidence:   12.2 meters
    99.73% confidence:   23.6 meters

    Alt
    50.00% confidence:   7.6 meters
    68.27% confidence:   10.8 meters
    95.45% confidence:   23.9 meters
    99.73% confidence:   39.5 meters

What this means is that a user taking a single non-DGPS correction can expect the reading to fall within 4.2 meters of the correct position 50% of the time. Similarly the reading should fall within 12.2 meters of the correct position 95% of the time.


GPS with DGPS corrections

DGPS M12 plot
    samples:             None yet
    ave lat:             
    ave lon:             
    ave alt:             
    50.00% confidence:   
    68.27% confidence:   
    95.45% confidence:   
    99.73% confidence:   

    Alt
    50.00% confidence:   
    68.27% confidence:   
    95.45% confidence:   
    99.73% confidence:   

The M12 Oncore ver-1.3 under test doesn't appear to work correctly with Coast Guard DGPS correction messages (Type-9/3). This test will have to wait for a firmware upgrade.


Caveats

The exact position of the rooftop antenna is not currently known. The position of the rooftop antenna is derived as the average of the 24 hour position. If there are any biases in the system, or if the GPS were to have an error in calculating its position correctly then some undetected errors could sneak in.

The height plotted here is what Motorola refers to as the "GPS height".


Running the tests yourself

The above statistics may be gathered with a home grown unix program I call salog. Feel free to grab the above distribution and run your own statistics. It should compile up with little difficulty under netbsd, freebsd, openbsd and linux.

You will have to put the Oncore into NMEA mode to use this program.


Valid XHTML 1.0!.Valid CSS! [ Powered by Fedora Core ] IPv6 Ready

wolfgang.rupprecht+web@gmail.com (Wolfgang S. Rupprecht)
WSRCC Home Page || Up One Level
last updated $Date: 2007/05/24 22:21:55 $ ..